Dumping the homeless and aged

JOSEPH MALIAKAN

The harsh north Indian winter is particularly unbearable for the poor and homeless aged people. For years scores of homeless people have been dying due to exposure to cold in North Indian cities. However, following court interventions and proactive policies adopted by municipal bodies the number of deaths due to exposure during the winter months in India has been considerably reduced.

Deaths due to exposure take place during summer also but deaths in the winter cold far outnumbered deaths in summer. Since 1980 cold waves have killed more Indians than heat waves according to Indian Meteorological Department (IMD ) data. In 23 years between 1980 and 2018 the human death toll in India due to cold waves was higher than due to heatwaves. For example in 1992 the deaths due to heatwave were 111 and cold wave 303; In 2011 it was 12 and 722 ( phenomenal increase) and in 2018 it was 16 and 136.

And as for cold waves according to the IMD between 2010 and 2018 there was a whopping 506 percent increase in the number of cold waves in India despite increasing temperatures worldwide due to global warming.

And in the new year as the cold wave was sweeping north India in late January 2021 came the shocking report of Indore Municipal Corporation employees rounding up sick homeless senior citizens and dumping them on the outskirts of the city.

On 29 January, a group of Indore municipal corporation workers went around the city and loaded 10 homeless people, including two elderly women into a corporation truck and dumped them in the outskirts of the city on the Indore-Dewas Road.

Rajesh Joshi a tea seller on the roadside captured the shocking incident on camera even as villagers vehemently objected to the inhuman act. Most of the people being dumped in the village on the outskirts of Indore city were old, sick and so debilitated that they could not even stand up straight without help.

The municipal workers told the villagers that they were dropping these people in the village on the orders of municipal officials because these homeless people were dirting the city. What explained the reason for the inhuman treatment of the elderly homeless people by the Indore Municipal Corporation?.

Indore has been judged the cleanest city in India for the fourth consecutive year in a raw and the city is currently making all-out efforts to win the ‘ Swachh Sarvekshan 2021’. Ironically, Indore is also among the 10 cities in India selected for the drive for rehabilitating beggars under the Central Social Justice Department’s scheme for identification, training and employment of beggars.
Unfortunately for the Indore Municipal Corporation, the video of the corporation workers dumping the homeless in a wayside village went viral inviting immediate reaction from the Chief Minister of Madhya Pradesh, the Madhya Pradesh Human Rights Commission, and several political leaders. So far the Indore Police which very recently arrested stand-up comedian Manwar Frooqui and others on charges of promoting communal harmony has not taken any action regarding the incidence of dumping the homeless senior citizens on the outskirts of the city.

The corporation following an inquiry sacked eight low-level employees and the Chief Minister ordered the suspension of a Deputy Municipal Commissioner. Available evidence from the video footage and reports in the media suggest that the dumping of the homeless on the highway was a deliberate act and it was the normal practice followed by the Indore corporation to keep the city clean.

This incident should be treated as a wake-up call for the rest of India to deliberate on the way in which we treat our senior citizens, especially the homeless senior citizens whose numbers are on the increase. With the population of senior citizens on the increase, they are facing more and problems with regard to shelter, food, medical care and entertainment opportunities.

Article 41 and 46 of the Indian Constitution has certain provisions for the elderly. Section 20 of the Hindu Marriage Adoption Act 1956, makes it obligatory to maintain aged parents. The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act 2007 makes it legal for children or heirs to maintain their parents or senior citizens of the family.

In 2010 India had 91.6million elderly and by 2025 India will have 158.7 elderly. Of the elderly 2/3 live in villages and 50 percent are dependents. Also, 70 percent of the elderly are women and poor. There is no proper data available on the abuse and neglect of senior citizens in the country but all available indicators report at police stations and in the media point out that both abuse and neglect of the elderly are on the increase.